European Financial and Accounting Journal
European Financial and Accounting Journal
European Financial and Accounting Journal
Faculty of Finance and Accounting, University of Economics, Prague

European Financial and Accounting Journal 2019/1

The Impact of Specific Reverse Charge on Waste and Scrap on Tax Revenues in the Czech Republic

DOI: https://doi.org/10.18267/j.efaj.223

[full text (PDF)]

Eliška Čejková, Hana Zídková

The paper is focused on VAT evasion and especially carousel frauds. It describes the types of VAT evasion, methods of its estimation and measures taken by the European member state to fight it. The aim of the article is to develop a reasonable method for assessing the volume of carousel fraud in the Czech Republic. It uses ex-post calculation of the impact of a specific reverse-charge implemented in the Czech Republic on waste and scrap in 2011. The analysis employs trade balance data of the Czech Republic published by the Czech Statistical Office and a model of the carousel fraud to estimate the size of the carousel fraud existing prior to the implementation of the specific reverse charge in the CR. The volume of the supposed carousels in waste and scrap present in the period from 1 April 2010 to 31 March 2011 in the CR is according to the authors EUR 56 mil. (approx. CZK 1.4 bn.).

Keywords: Carousel fraud, Specific reverse charge, VAT evasion

JEL Classification: H26

References:

Ainsworth, R. T., 2006. Carousel Fraud in the EU: A Digital Vat Solution. Boston Univ. School of Law, Law and Economics Research Paper No. 06-23. Available from: <bu.edu/law/workingpapers-archive/documents/ainsworthr081006.pdf.>. [10 June 2018].

Bodin, J. P., Ebrill, E.P., Keen, M., Summers, V. P.,2001. Modern VAT. International Monetary Fund, Washington, DC. DOI: 10.5089/9781589060265.071.

CFE Tax Advisors Europe (CFE), 2018. Opinion Statement FC 7/2018 on a Proposal for a Council Directive amending Directive 2006/112/EC, as regards the introduction of the detailed technical measures for the operation of the definitive VAT system for the taxation of trade between Member States. Brussels. Available from: <ibfd.org/IBFD-Products/Journal-Articles/European-Taxation/collections/et/ html/et_2018_12_cfe_1.html>. [4 June 2019].

Czech Statistical Office (CSO),2019. Database of International Trade, Available from: <apl.czso.cz/pll/stazo/STAZO.STAZO>. [9 June 2019].

D’agosto, E., Marigliani, M., Pisani, S., 2014). Asymmetries in the Territorial Vat Gap [Discussion topics]. Italian Revenue Agency. Rome. Available from: <researchgate.net/profile/Stefano_Pisani/publication/270568601_Asymmetries_in_the_territorial_vat_gap/links/54ae65210cf2828b29fce2ae.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

European Commission,2014. Assessment of the application and impact of the optional ‘Reverse Charge Mechanism’ within the EU VAT system. Executive Summary, Specific Contract No 6 TAXUD/2013/DE/333 implementing Framework Contract No TAXUD/2012/CC/117, DOI: 10.2778/578675.

European Commission,2016. The concept of Tax Gaps. Report on VAT Gap Estimations, FISCALIS Tax Gap Project Group, FPG/041. Available from:<ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/sites/taxation/files/docs/body/tgpg_report_en.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

European Commission, 2016. Towards a single EU VAT area - Time to decide. Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council and the European Economic and Social Committee on an action plan on VAT, COM (2016) 148 final. Available from: <eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=COM%3A2016%3A148%3AFIN>. [9 June 2019].

European Commission, 2017. Impact Assessment. Accompanying the document Proposal for a Council Directive amending Directive 2006/112/EC as regards harmonizing and simplifying certain rules in the value added tax system and introducing the definitive system for the taxation of trade between Member States, Commission Staff Working Document SWD (2017) 325 final. Available from: <ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/sites/taxation/files/18012018_impactassessment_proposal_vat_rates_en.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

European Commission, 2018. Taxation Trends in the EU, Luxembourg. ISBN 978-92-79-79838-2.Available from: <ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/sites/ taxation/files/taxation_trends_report_2018.pdf> [9 June 2019].

EY, 2017. Romania publishes Ordinance on implementation of VAT split payment mechanism, Indirect Tax Alert. Available from:<ey.com/gl/en/services/tax/international-tax/alert--romania-publishes-ordinance-on-implementation-of-vat-split-payment-mechanism>. [9 June 2019].

Fedeli, S., Forte, F., 2011. EU VAT frauds. European Journal of Law and Economics. 31. Available from: <EconPapers.repec.org/RePEc:bap:journl: 120406>. [9 June 2019].

Frunza, M., 2013. Aftermath of the VAT fraud on carbon emissions markets, Journal of Financial Crime, Vol. 20 Issue: 2, pp.222-236, DOI: 10.1108/13590791311322382.

Hallam, N., 2017. EU tax authorities: Anti-fraud measures and a grab for cash, Accountancy Age. Available from: <accountancyage.com/2017/09/13/eu-tax-authorities-anti-fraud-measures-and-a-grab-for-cash/>. [9 June 2019].

Hansson, A., Wallberg, K., 2008. Tax Gap Map for Sweden. How was it created and how can it be used? Swedish National Tax Agency, Solna. Available from: <skatteverket.se/download/18.361dc8c15312eff6fd2b9a4/1473840293366/Report_2008_1B.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

HM CUSTOMS AND EXCISE, 2018, Measuring Tax Gaps 2016-2017. Available from: <assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/715742/HMRC-measuring-tax-gaps-2018.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

Hillman, A.I., 2009. Public Finance and Public Policy - Responsibilities and Limitations of Government. Cambridge University Press. ISBN-13 978-0-511-64127-5.

Chiarini, B., Marzano, E., & Schneider, F., 2009. Tax Rates and Tax Evasion: An Empirical Analysis of Structural Aspects and Long-Run Characteristics in Italy. IZA, Working Paper no. 3447. DOI: 10.1111/j.0042-7092.2007.00700.x.

Keen, M., & Smith, S., 2007. VAT Fraud and Evasion: What do We Know and What can be Done? International Monetary Fund (IMF), Working Paper no. 07/31. Available from: <imf.org/en/Publications/WP/Issues/2016/12/31/VAT-Fraud-and-Evasion-What-Do-We-Know-and-What-Can-be-Done-20215>. [9 June 2019].

Krikorian-Slade, B., 2017. HMRC: Call for Input on Alternative method of VAT collection. Response from UK Finance. Available from: <ukfinance.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/170714-UK-Finance-conres-HMRC-Alternative-method-of-VAT-collection-v1.0.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

Nam, Chang Woon and Gebauer, Andrea and Parsche, Rüdiger, 2003. Is the Completion of the EU Single Market Hindered by Vat Evasion? CESifo Working Paper Series No. 974. Available from: <ssrn.com/abstract=427624>. [9 June 2019].

Novysedlák, V., & Palkovičová, J., 2012. Estimate of Value Added Tax Revenue Loss. Institute for Financial Policy. Ministry of Finance of the SR. Bratislava. Available from: <finance.gov.sk/en/finance/institute-financial-policy/working-papers/the-estimate-value-added-tax-revenue-loss/>. [9 June 2019].

Parsche, R., 2008. Trotz Erhöhung des Mehrwertsteuersatzes 2007 auf 19% ging die Ausfallquote auf 9% zurück und dürfte auch 2008 bei 9% liegen [Although VAT rate was increased to 19%, the VAT gap redued to 9%]., vol. 61, no. 12, pp. 55–56. Available from:<researchgate.net/publication/46548672_Trotz_Erhohung _des_Mehrwertsteuersatzes_2007_auf_19_ging_die_Ausfallquote_auf_9_zuruck_und_durfte_auch_2008_bei_9_liegen>. [9 June 2019].

van Duyne, P., C., Harvey, J., Maljević, A., Scheinost, M., von Lampe, K., 2008. European crime-markets at cross-roads: Extended and extending criminal Europe (pp. 237-259). Nijmegen, the Netherlands: Wolf Legal. Available from: <cross-border-crime.net/freecopies/CCC_intro_2008a_CrossRoads.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

Poniatowski, G., 2016. VAT non-compliance in Poland under scrutiny. CASE Seminar Proceedings, No. 142/2016 CASE. Warsaw. DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.2813160.

Poniatowski, G., Bonch-Osmolovskiy, M., Durán-Cabré, J. M., Esteller-Moré, A., & Śmietanka, A., 2018. CASE reports: Study and reports on the VAT gap in the EU-28 member states: 2018 final report. CASE Network Studies and Analyses., (496), 1-87. Available from: <ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/ sites/taxation/files/2018_vat_gap_report_en.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

PWC, 2007. Study in respect of introducing an optional reverse charge mechanism in the EU VAT Directive. Final Report to the European Commission TAXUD/2007/DE/305. Available from: <ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/sites/ taxation/files/resources/documents/common/consultations/tax/4209_study_en.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

Reckon LLP, 2009. Study to Quantify and Analyse the VAT Gap in the EU-25 Member States. Reckon Report. Available from: <ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/sites/taxation/files/docs/body/reckon_report_sep2009.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

Romania Fiscal Council, 2011. Annual Report. Macroeconomic and Fiscal Developments. Available from: <fiscalcouncil.ro/annualreport2012.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

Sergiou, L., 2012. Value Added Tax (VAT) Carousel Fraud in the European Union. Journal of Accounting and Management (JAM). Vol. 2. 9-21. Available from: <journals.univ-danubius.ro/index.php/jam/article/view/1428>. [9 June 2019].

Tait, A. A., 1988. Value Added Tax: International Practice and Problems, International Monetary Fund. Washington, DC. ISBN-13: 978-1557750129.

Terra, B. Kajus, J., 2018. A Guide to the European VAT Directives 2018. IBFD. 2018 ISBN 978-90-8722-437-0 (vol. 1).

Thackray, M., & Ueda, J., 2014. Technical Assistance Report—Revenue Administration Gap Analysis Program. The Value-Added Tax Gap. Republic of Estonia. International Monetary Fund (IMF), Report no. 14/133. Available from: <imf.org/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/cr14133.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

Thackray, M., Hutton, E., Kapoor, K. 2015. Finland - Revenue Administration Gap Analysis Program. The Value-Added Tax Gap. International Monetary Fund (IMF), Report no. 16/60. Available from:<imf.org/external/pubs/ft/scr/2016/cr1660.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

TPA, 2017. Poland 2018: Voluntary VAT Split Payment. Available from: <tpa-group.com/en/publications-news/news/poland-2018-voluntary-vat-split-payment>. [9 June 2019].

UK Office for National Statistics, 2016. VAT missing trader intra-Community fraud: the effect on Balance of Payments, Economic trends. Available from: <assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/269872/GSSMethodspaper_v6.0.pdf>. [9 June 2019].

Weisbach, D.A., Bankman, J., 2006. The Superiority of an Ideal Consumption Tax over an Ideal Income Tax, 58 Stanford Law Review 1413. DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.758645.

Weisbach, D.A., Bankman, J. 2007. Consumption Taxation Is Still Superior to Income Taxation (John M. Olin Program in Law and Economics Working Paper No.358, 2007). Available from: <jstor.org/stable/40040365?seq=1#page_scan_tab_contents>. [9 June 2019].